MP3, WAV, M4A, FLAC: which audio format for what?
The same recording can weigh 3 MB or 30 MB depending on its format. What separates the main audio formats, which one to choose, and what a conversion can and cannot do.
A voice memo that will not attach to an e-mail, a music file the car stereo refuses to play, a recording an online form does not accept. Behind these everyday annoyances there is nearly always a question of format. A few notions are enough to choose well.
Two families
Uncompressed or lossless formats keep all the recorded sound.
- WAV stores the sound as it is. It is the reference for editing and for archives. It is also heavy: about 10 MB per minute at CD quality.
- FLAC compresses without losing anything, a little like a ZIP file for sound. Same quality as WAV, roughly half the size.
Compressed formats remove the parts of the sound the ear notices least.
- MP3 is read by virtually every device and program. At a good bitrate, about 1 to 2.5 MB per minute.
- M4A (AAC) is the usual format of recordings and music on Apple devices. At the same size it generally sounds a little better than MP3, but some older players do not read it.
- OGG and Opus are open formats, common in voice messages and on the web, less widely supported by music players.
Which one to choose
| You want to… | Choose |
|---|---|
| Send a recording by e-mail or messaging | MP3 |
| Play a file on any device | MP3 |
| Edit or mix the sound | WAV |
| Archive at full quality in less space | FLAC |
| Meet the requirement of a platform or a program | The format it asks for |
What a conversion can and cannot do
Converting to a compressed format reduces the size and removes a little information. Done once, at a good bitrate, the difference is hard to hear.
The opposite is not true. Converting an MP3 to WAV gives a larger file, compatible with programs that require WAV, but the sound removed by the MP3 compression does not come back. For the same reason, avoid chains of conversions: each pass through a compressed format loses a little more. When you can, start again from the original recording.
Converting
- A WAV that is too heavy to send: WAV to MP3.
- A program that only accepts WAV: MP3 to WAV.
- A recording from an iPhone or a Mac for a device that does not read it: M4A to MP3.
- An album in FLAC for a player that does not support it: FLAC to MP3.
- A voice message in OGG or Opus: OGG to MP3 or Opus to MP3.
A file can weigh up to 30 MB. A long WAV recording quickly exceeds that: cut it into parts before converting.